Tuesday, January 6, 2009

Reading Responses

The Rules of the Game - Eric Zimmerman

I found this article really interesting. I think it is fair to say that almost everyone has some familiarity with boardgames, but the context in which more modern generations live in greatly defines how we think of them. I grew up in a time where I can't really remember not having the internet, even as a child. So when I hear the word interactive, or even game, I immediatley think of electronic or even internet based games, like the author mentions in the article. For me personally, thinking of boardgames makes me think of something I used to do as a child, and something I do very rarely now, when I get together with family. I really enjoyed the perspective the author was able to provide on board games, being someone who is not only is extremely knowledgeable in the subject, but was around before electronic and internet games dominated the field. I would also be interested to hear how other people from previous generations view boardgames. The author does make the comparison of boardgames to the current multiplayer games played through internet connections, however I think they are still so much more passive than boardgames. One big difference between the two is rules, in the case of boardgames all of the players are in charge of enforcing/abiding by the rules, but in the case of electronic games, the rules are almost always governed by the game it self.



Rules, Play, and Culture - Frank Lantz & Eric Zimmerman

To me this article seemed like from the beggining it's main goal was to define what a game is at the core, and the different ways that they manifest. What I found really interesting was the extreme contrast between rules and the complexity of play. While the rules for a game can be quite simple, the actual outcome and process of play varies enormously depending on a large number of factors during game play. The concept of "designed play" was also something that I found interesting. When I think of design, I generally think of something that is created, tangible, and for the most part unchanging. However designing "play" is like designing an experience, one that is flexible and subjective. In the article the authors also stressed the importance of social interaction and games, whether its a boardgame or a video game. There are a lot of games that are designed to be played by one player, but I have noticed even in my own life that playing games with other people (even when its through an internet connection with people you don't know) can be much more gratifying that playing by yourself.



Knowledge Maps - Marek Kohn

This article seemed to focus on both the importance of knowledge for modern companies, and the difficulty of effectively managing that knowledge. I found it really interesting how much of a value knowledge really holds, even though it is not a tangible thing. I also found it interesting how the author broke down the differences between data, information, and knowledge. Ultimately I came away from the article being somewhat confused as to how a knowledge map should actually be constructed. It also seemed like the problem that companies face when it comes to managing knowledge is still not completely resolved. That being said, the article definitely made it clear that managing knowledge is extremely crucial, regardless of the challenges that it actually creates. This is something I will keep in mind, and apply to my work in the future.

No comments:

Post a Comment